|
||||||
|
POOLS TOLD TO CLEAN UP
ACT
DOZENS OF AREA POOLS, SPAS FAIL INSPECTIONS Orlando Sentinel Across Central Florida, people playing in pools and spas at hotels, condominiums, fitness centers, schools and city parks are at risk for a slew of diseases that can cause everything from diarrhea to death. An Orlando Sentinel review of more than 4,000 county health-department inspection reports in five counties revealed that 151 pools and 51 spas failed to meet the state's minimum chlorine standards during checks this year. More than 100 pools had zero chlorine, the potent weapon that fights bacteria, including the deadly E. coli, a tiny organism that three years ago killed two children infected by it at an Atlanta water park. Violators in Central Florida ranged from the spa at the exclusive Wyndham Palace Resort on the grounds of Walt Disney World to the Winter Park High School pool, from a Mount Dora municipal pool in a poor neighborhood to the spa at the tony Paramount Health Club in Orlando. In Volusia County, a string of beachfront mom-and-pop motels on Atlantic Avenue flunked, as did the Grand Seas Resort in Daytona Beach, which markets its condominiums as a "five-star resort." Inspectors noted the wading pool for children was "extremely green."
Orlando's popular water parks checked in with clean records. Nobody knows how many bathers are getting sick from bacteria in public "Very few people know that they can get sick from swimming,"
said Sean Kaufman, health-communications specialist at the CDC's division of parasitic control. "Everybody always
thinks it's caused by what they've eaten." That's because the symptoms of such infections include vomiting and dysentery. In more serious cases,
the swimmer can suffer fever, jaundice, seizures, kidney failure or death. The symptoms often hit two days or more after exposure,
and most of the diseases are highly contagious. "If
a pool has zero chlorine, you are asking for a disease outbreak to occur," said Suzanne Grubbs, an environmental
specialist at the Volusia County Health Department in Daytona Beach. FREQUENT CHECKS ARE CRUCIAL Most
outbreaks are preventable by simple maintenance that pool operators can -- and are required by law -- to perform.
For example, state law says they must check the water once a day for the proper chlorine level. Many don't bother. At the Caravel
Motel in Daytona Beach, for example, a pool inspector spent a month trying to get the operator to put enough
chlorine in the pool to pass the inspection. Finally, the inspector posted a sign: "Warning! POOL
CLOSED! Use of this pool may be hazardous to your health." Chlorine doesn't guarantee a safe pool, though. Some bugs don't die when they're
hit with the chemical. "If I were to take a bowl
of water and wash your feet and hands in it and pour it in a glass and ask you to swish it in your mouth, who would do that?"
asked Kaufman. "That's what you're doing in some of these pools." ORANGE, OSCEOLA LEAD LIST Orange
and Osceola counties had the largest number of chlorine violations -- 86 and 51, respectively. Nearly 10 percent of Osceola's
530 pools and spas failed; 4.6 percent flunked in Orange, where there are 1,862 pools and spas. Those two counties topped the list because of the number of
hotels and motels within their boundaries. With 66 violations, Orange and Osceola's tourist spots were the worst offenders
when it comes to chlorine violations. In Lake County,
22 or 8.4 percent of 260 pools and spas failed; in Volusia, 3.8 percent, or 39 of the county's 1,021 pools
were below standards. Seminole County had the most-sanitary pools and spas -- only three of 490 or 0.6 percent
had too little chlorine. Apartment complexes, motels
and hotels account for 56 percent of all violations. Pools and spas at condominiums and mobile-home parks were
the next-biggest violators, followed by neighborhood and community pools, and then those found at country clubs. School pools and those at fitness
centers and health clubs generally fared well, but both the Winter Park High School swimming pool and the spa
at Paramount Health Club in Orlando did not have enough chlorine to meet the state's minimum of 1 part per million of
chlorine for a pool and 2 parts per million for a spa. Both have since met the standard. "I don't even want to see a pool operating at 1 part per million," said
Bob Pryor, environmental specialist with the Florida Department of Health. "You Two city pools failed -- Winter
Garden's Bouler Pool at Zanders Park and the Lincoln Avenue Recreation Pool in Mount Dora, in
the heart of the city's black community. "What
timing," said Scott Simphor, Mount Dora's community-services director. He said lightning struck the pool's automatic chlorinator on April 19 -- the evening
before the inspector showed up. Staffers thought the machine was working properly when they checked it in the morning. In the west Orange city of Winter Garden,
a tube that feeds the chlorinator was clogged when the inspector arrived June 8, said Larry Caskey, the recreation director. "It happens all the time -- usually
our maintenance person gets it but this time he didn't," Caskey said. 'OFF-THE-WALL STUFF' Officials
said they hear the same explanations from pool operators: rain diluted the water, the chlorinator broke or the
pool company did not deliver chemicals on time. In those cases, state officials said, operators should close
the pools. "Others say 'The sun
burned out the chlorine,' or 'I have the chemicals checked twice a week -- what more do you want?' "
Anderson said. "Or they say 'What do you need chlorine for? It rots bathing suits.' I hear a lot of off-the-wall
stuff." Sixteen mobile-home parks in
the five counties flunked the inspection. At the Palm Ridge Mobile Home Park in Leesburg, manager Becky Pasdash blamed an
unsatisfactory review of the park's pool on a broken chlorinator and bad timing. "We spent, like, $6,000 to fix the problems. It's running fine now," Pasdash said earlier
this week. Paul Sanan, manager of the
Days Inn in Daytona Beach, blamed the hotel's failing spa inspection on its former pool company. "They were not always showing up,"
he said. Now, the pool
is serviced three times a week by a new company, he said. When inspectors find no chlorine, they watch while the person in charge of the pool corrects
the problem, or they close the pool. "They
don't want to close it, because it hurts their business. I understand the predicament they're in, but I am entrusted
with the health code," said Andy Anderson, a pool inspector for the Orange County Health Department. MANY SWIMMERS UNAWARE When management fails to respond, inspectors usually tell the swimmers about the pool's
condition -- and those folks are usually shocked. University
of Central Florida student Olivia Alicea was dismayed to learn the pool at her apartment complex had no chlorine
when tested June 13. The 19-year-old said her infant niece often visits, and they play together in the "It's
freaking me out to think my niece could get something in the pool," she said. "If it's something
you can't see, that's scary." But At Deerwood
Mobile Home Park off Colonial Drive in east Orange County, 15-year-old Melissa Roman wasn't surprised to learn that two
of the park's three pools had no chlorine when tested July 3. "I won't touch the wading pool -- that's the disgusting one. It smells
all the time," said Melissa, who lives at the park. "At the back pool, you can feel the green slime
under your feet. It's just nasty." But Roman
and her buddies swim anyway -- they're desperate to escape the heat. Most pool operators -- particularly those who run motels and hotels -- act quickly when
a pool inspector threatens to close down the fun for guests. But not all. Records show
that one of the most egregious violators was the Caravel Motel in Daytona Beach, where an inspector found no chlorine in the
pool June 29 and noted on a report that management was not keeping the required written daily log of maintenance
and testing. The inspector closed the pool and made arrangements to re-check it the next day. Still no chlorine. Inspector Brian Volkman found the same conditions later that day, and on July 2 the motel had not yet met chlorine standards. All it would have taken to pass was an inexpensive pack of chlorine available at discount stores. Volkman finally posted a sign at the pool warning bathers of the health hazard.
On July 3, Caravel got the
OK to reopen the pool. The operator, Fadel Elbadramy, could not be reached for comment. Many pool operators who flunked inspections did not want to discuss why they failed. "I have no comment," said Judy
Ruggieri, manager at Ocean Oaks Apartments in Port Orange, where an inspector noted in May that the pool was
so green he couldn't see the main drain. WHAT'S
LURKING BENEATH Among the illnesses swimmers
risk getting in pools with too little chlorine, according to the CDC, are: Gastroenteritis, an inflammation of the digestive tract, which can cause diarrhea, stomach cramps,
vomiting, and fever. The bacteria and virus can live in soil, anim ls and humans. Legionnaire's disease, which usually
causes fever, chills and a cough, and sometimes muscle aches, headache, fatigue and loss of appetite It can also harm
kidney function. The bacteria reproduce to high numbers in warm water. Giardiasis, a diarrheal illness caused by a parasite that lives in the intestines of people and animals. Salmonellosis, which causes diarrhea, fever
and abdominal cramps. In severe Shigellosis, an illness that causes diarrhea, fever and stomach cramps. A severe infection with high
fever may also cause seizures in children younger than 2. Hepatitis A, a virus that causes jaundice, fatigue, abdominal pain, nausea Swimmers often don't know a pool made them sick because symptoms sometimes don't
appear until a week after bathing, said the CDC's Kaufman. Many of the diseases are highly contagious and can spread to
others long after the infected person leaves the pool. Some require a specific antibiotic, while others must
run their course. Even in the cleanest pools,
however, people can be attacked by bacteria. Florida last year reported six outbreaks of cryptosporidium, a parasite that can survive in chlorinated water for days. In 1999, the state had three outbreaks, compared with one in 1998 and none in the previous three years.
It can cause a month's
worth of nausea, vomiting, fever, abdominal cramping, and profuse diarrhea. "Everything used to get killed by chlorine," Kaufman said. "Now there are things surviving
and thriving." Five of the 38 swimmers sickened
in 2000 fell ill after swimming at the Ormond Holiday Club condominium pool in Volusia County. That occurred
when a family from Ohio -- where there had been a cryptosporidium outbreak – visited the pool, and their
infant in diapers had bowel movements in the water two days in a row. Another swimmer notified condo staffers, who immediately closed the pool, shocked it
with chlorine for nine hours, vacuumed it and cleaned the filters. Though staffers followed state guidelines for cleanup,
five people fell ill anyway. TREATMENT NOT COMPLICATED Pool inspectors say mastering the art of pool science is not difficult -- anyone can easily become a poolside chemist with an inexpensive kit available at discount and pool stores.
Homeowners should make sure chlorine is regularly fed into pool water and should test
the water daily. Pools used by the public should be tested more than the required once a day. "It's not as critical with a home pool, but when you get all kinds of people
from all over the world swimming in a pool, it can be critical," said Jim Crago, sanitation safety supervisor
at the Orange County Health Department. Along with
low-chlorine violations, dozens of other Central Florida pools failed inspections because they had too much chlorine.
A Volusia County pool inspector temporarily closed the spa at Martinique Condo in Ponce Inlet, noting
that it had chlorine levels "off the charts." Too much chlorine can bleach clothes but is not likely to cause health
problems. Ironically, if the odor of
chlorine is strong and if swimmers' eyes are red and burn, that's often an indication that there isn't enough
chlorine or that the pH is too low or too high, Kaufman said. The higher the pH, the less likely the chlorine will do its
job. HOW CAN YOU TELL? The CDC is trying to get the word out to the public in its first education campaign about water-borne
illnesses. The agency has a detailed Internet site on the to ic and has contracted with two Olympic swimmers to appear on
posters warning the public of the danger. The most
important thing people should know: If it looks cloudy, green, black or mustard-colored, don't jump in. Ditto if it smells. "I've seen pools so
green you couldn't see the bottom of it, and people were swimming in it," said Anderson. Kaufman said people "need to be very cautious." He recommended that swimmers ask questions
about pool maintenance, and if they are unsure, visit their county health department to review a pool's
inspection report. |
||||||
|
|
||||||